Our Opinion: Constitutional amendment fever

News Tribune editorial

Before elevating additional activity to a constitutional right, Missouri lawmakers may want to heed the advice of Robot B-9.

The robot, you may recall, was programmed to warn the stranded family of impending danger on the 1960s television program, "Lost in Space."

Some lawmakers - in past sessions and, notably, during this session - perceive attacks on what they consider traditional behavior and activities.

A tendency has been to repel those attacks by enshrining specific activities and behaviors as constitutional rights.

A partial list of proposed constitutional amendments includes:

• A right to farm.

• A right to hunt and fish.

• A right to hold a rodeo.

• A right for parents to raise their children as they see fit.

Are these proposals a reasonable response to a real threat or an over-reaction fueled by paranoia?

Two factors aggravating this constitutional amendment fever, if we may call it that, are Proposition B and term limits.

Proposition B was an animal welfare law - not a constitutional amendment - approved by voters, but changed drastically by lawmakers before it became effective.

The action provided a compelling example of why a constitutional amendment is preferable; it is impervious to legislative tampering.

In addition, term limits fuel a tendency among lawmakers to pass measures with greater durability. Perhaps it is political equivalent of the psychological longing to create something that continues after we're gone .

The tendency to enshrine activity and behavior as a constitutional right, however, presents both short-term and long-term consequences.

The immediate concern is if a constitutional amendment permits abuse, the error cannot be rectified quickly.

The long-range consequence, as we wrote in this forum on Feb. 2 is: "If we continue on this inane path of continually amending the constitution, representative government eventually will become superfluous."

A constitution is a framework for governing; it is not a law book or regulation manual.

To paraphrase Robot B-9: Danger, Missouri Legislature, danger!

Upcoming Events