Mom: Girl who died after fight described 1 punch
Wednesday, February 29, 2012
LONG BEACH, Calif. (AP) — Cecilia Villanueva sat helplessly in the backseat and watched her 10-year-old daughter turn blue as her husband raced them to the hospital in a panic.
Earlier, the fifth-grader, Joanna Ramos, had come home from school vomiting and complaining of a headache after a fight with another girl.
Before she passed out on the family couch, she told her mother an 11-year-old girl had punched her in the head.
“I could see her lips turning purple and I got so scared. I tried to do CPR,” her mother said Tuesday, choking back tears. “I tried my best, but when we got to the hospital they said her heart was stopped. They tried, they tried so hard.”
Joanna was pronounced dead on Friday night after undergoing emergency surgery for a blood clot on her brain, her 17-year-old sister, Vanessa Urbina, said.
The Los Angeles County coroner’s office labeled the case a homicide and said Joanna died of blunt force trauma to the head. Police said they have made no arrests and were conducting an investigation that will be presented to prosecutors when it’s completed.
The girl’s family and friends are stunned and struggling to understand how a schoolyard fight over a boy could end in death for a bubbly girl who loved to dance and sing, religiously followed soap operas on TV, and had a penchant for curling her long, dark hair. Joanna would have turned 11 on March 12.
Villanueva said she is certain her daughter didn’t tell her the whole story, and she is wary of believing the rumors that have been circulating among Joanna’s classmates.
Police have said the fight in an alley after school on Friday lasted less than a minute, involved no weapons and no one fell to the ground.
“I told the doctor what happened and he said, ‘One punch is not enough, the way that she is right now,’” Villanueva said. “My daughter told me one punch, only, just one. And the doctor said, ‘Hmmm, I don’t think so. One wouldn’t cause too much damage.’”
Villanueva, 41, said before Joanna lost consciousness, she told her mother the other girl was her “enemy” but offered no further explanation.
While the circumstances of Joanna’s death are tragic and extremely unusual, medical experts said a blow in just the right spot can often prove fatal.
“This is rare, in that I’ve never seen it in a female, certainly not in a female adolescent,” said Dr. Keith Black, a neurosurgeon at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center.
Black, who was not involved in Joanna’s medical care, sees such injuries all the time among older patients, and said a blow to the head from one young girl to another could “absolutely” be sufficient to cause enough trauma to lead to death.
Punches to the head can often lead to delayed bleeding if a vein is torn, and that can lead to a clot when blood collects on the surface of the brain.
School officials believe the fight occurred near the school in a 15-minute window between the time school let out and the start of Joanna’s after-school program at 2:30 p.m., said Chris Eftychiou, a spokesman for the Long Beach Unified School District.
Joanna didn’t have any visible injuries or show any signs of distress for about an hour, but she eventually told staff she felt unwell and was picked up by a relative, he said.
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Please review our Policies and Procedures before registering or commenting