Univision denies it tried to coerce US senator
Tuesday, October 4, 2011
MIAMI (AP) — The Univision television network denied allegations Tuesday that it told Republican Sen. Marco Rubio it might not broadcast a story about a relative's decades-old drug conviction if he appeared on its news programs.
The story about his brother-in-law's late 1980s cocaine trafficking conviction ran in July and Rubio did not appear on the network. The Spanish-language network says it never used the story to pressure Rubio to appear. Rubio's spokesman declined comment to The Associated Press but told The Miami Herald that the network's head of news insinuated the offer on a conference call. That description of the call matched a similar account that the newspaper obtained from separate sources.
The allegations prompted three Hispanic Republican leaders to call for Republican presidential candidates to boycott Univision's efforts to plan a debate in January. Mitt Romney, Rick Perry and Jon Huntsman said Tuesday they would boycott.
Univision has long sought Rubio as a guest on its network news programs, where he would likely face tough questions from top anchors Jorge Ramos and Maria Elena Salinas about his conservative stance on immigration reform. Univision denies it ever tried to use the story to pressure Rubio into appearing.
Univision heavily promoted its July 11 story on the late 1980s conviction of Orlando Cicilia, the husband of Rubio's sister, during the federal-led "Operation Cobra." Marco Rubio was 16 at the time and had nothing to do with the case. Cicilia was given early release in 2000. The in-depth story was widely ignored by English-language media because of a lack of relevance to the senator's political career.
The Herald first reported Saturday allegations that on a July conference call with Rubio staff, Univision president of news Isaac Lee insinuated the network would tone down or pull the story if Rubio appeared on one of its news programs. The Herald story cited unnamed Univision sources, as well as notes from Rubio's staff members who it said matched the reported account.
Rubio officials told the AP on Tuesday that they did speak to the Herald about the allegations until after the Univision sources came forward and they have decided not to make further statements about the story.
Univision said in a statement that several participants were on the call with Rubio's office for an "off-the-record discussion" about the cocaine story, including two of its top lawyers. The company said it has not announced any planned debate or reached out to any candidates.
"Univision News is the leading source of news and information for the U.S. Hispanic community and this is a responsibility that we take very seriously," the company said in a statement. "With respect to Senator Rubio, Univision covered the (cocaine) story in the same objective, fair manner we cover every significant story. Univision did not offer to soften or spike a story about a major drug bust involving Senator Rubio's relatives. We would not make such an offer to any other subject of a news story and did not offer it in this case."
Following the telephone call with Lee and other Univision officials, Rubio spokesman Alex Burgos wrote Univision President Randy Falco on July 8, stating "we were disappointed and disturbed by the editorial policy your team made clear that Univision has now adopted when covering private persons who are completely uninvolved in politics, but simply happened to be related to a public official." The letter did not make any mention of the alleged quid-pro-quo.
In a response to that letter, Lee emphasized the network's integrity and balance.
He also added, "It is unfortunate that up to this point (Rubio) has declined multiple requests to sit down with our network news team for Al Punto (To the Point) or Aqui y Ahora (Here and Now) and hope he reconsiders our invitation to address issues of great concern to our community, including the current debt negotiations."
The candidate boycott is in response to a letter longtime Rubio friend and political ally Rep. David Rivera and two other Florida Republican leaders wrote Monday to Republican National Committee Chairman Reince Priebus and the party's nine presidential candidates.
Miami-Dade Republican Chairman Erik Fresen and Florida House Majority Leader Carlos Lopez-Cantera also signed the letter, which also demands that Univision issue an apology to Rubio and his family and fire Lee.
Romney's spokeswoman Andrea Saul said Tuesday that the former Massachusetts governor had not yet been contacted regarding any Univision debate, "but we are troubled by these allegations and would not participate in any such debate unless and until Univision satisfactorily addresses this situation."
Perry's campaign similarly said the Texas governor would not participate in a Univision campaign until the network addressed what it termed "an ethical breach."
A spokesman for Huntsman also confirmed the former Utah governor would boycott any proposed Univision debate.
Herman Cain's campaign said he would also decline any invitation from the network.
Rick Santorum's campaign said the candidate was reviewing the matter.
Other candidates did not immediately return email or telephone messages requesting comment.
More like this story
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Please review our Policies and Procedures before registering or commenting