Smart says she is thrilled after guilty verdict
Saturday, December 11, 2010
SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — Elizabeth Smart waited more than eight years for the word she heard Friday.
“Guilty,” the court clerk said, after a federal jury deliberated five hours to convict street preacher Brian David Mitchell of snatching Smart from her bed, at knifepoint in the dead of night, and forcing sex on her while he held her captive for nine months.
Smart smiled as the verdict was read, while a bedraggled, bearded Mitchell sat at the defense table, singing hymns with his hands before his chest, as if in prayer.
“I hope that not only is this an example that justice can be served in America, but that it is possible to move on after something terrible has happened,” Smart said, after she walked arm-in-arm with her mother through a crush of media.
It was a dramatic end to a tale that captured the nation’s attention since she disappeared in June 2002: A 14-year-old girl mysteriously taken from her home, the intense search and her eventual discovery walking Salt Lake City’s streets with her captors.
Smart, now 23, flew back from her Mormon mission in Paris to take the stand, and recount her “nine months of hell.”
“The beginning and the end of this story is attributable to a woman with extraordinary courage and extraordinary determination, and that’s Elizabeth Smart,” federal prosecutor Carlie Christensen said outside the courthouse.
“She did it with candor and clarity and a truthfulness that I think moved all of us,” she said.
Smart described in excruciating detail how she woke up one night to the feel of a cold, jagged knife at her throat and being whisked away by Mitchell to his camp in the foothills near the family’s Salt Lake City home.
Within hours of the kidnapping, she testified, she was forced into a polygamous marriage with him. She was tethered to a metal cable and subjected to near-daily rapes while being forced to use alcohol and drugs.
The five-week trial turned on the question of Mitchell’s mental health.
The thinly built, gray-haired Mitchell was routinely removed from the courtroom after loudly singing hymns and Christmas carols and taken to another room to watch the proceedings on closed circuit TV.
He kept his eyes closed in court and never spoke to anyone, including his lawyers.
His lawyers did not dispute that he kidnapped Smart but wanted him to be found not guilty by reason of insanity. Such a verdict would have sent him to a prison mental hospital.
Prosecutors countered that Mitchell was faking mental illness to avoid a conviction, labeling him a “predatory chameleon.”
Smart testified she believed Mitchell was driven by his desire for sex, drugs and alcohol, not by any sincere religious beliefs.
Jurors did not buy the insanity defense, finding him guilty of kidnapping and unlawful transportation of a minor across state lines for the purposes of illegal sex. The sex charge was based on Mitchell taking her for five of the nine months to California.
As the verdicts were read, the shackled Mitchell sat singing about Jesus Christ on the cross. Smart then turned to her mother and both smiled. Elizabeth Smart later hugged prosecutors.
“It’s real!” father Ed Smart said on his way out of the packed courtroom, giving a thumbs up. The comment echoed what he told a crowd gathered around a church on March 13, 2003, confirming that his daughter had been found.
Smart and her family had hoped for the guilty verdict and a long sentence.
Mitchell could face up to life in prison when he is sentenced on May 25. However, a judge also could impose an unspecified, lesser sentence, prosecutors said.
To the chagrin of the family, the case was delayed for years after Mitchell was declared mentally incompetent to stand trial in state court and a judge refused to order involuntary medications.
Federal prosecutors later stepped in and took the case to trial.
Christensen, the U.S. attorney, said one of the biggest challenges of the case was the six years between the time of the kidnapping and the time the case came into the federal justice system.
A parade of experts took the witness stand to say Mitchell had an array of diagnoses, from a rare delusional disorder and schizophrenia to pedophilia, anti-social personality disorder and narcissism.
Mitchell’s former stepdaughter told reporters that she was shocked that jurors didn’t see that he was mentally ill.
“He honestly believes God tells him to do these things,” Rebecca Woodridge said.
Mitchell had told defense attorneys he “expected to be convicted” as part of religous tests and seemed somehow unaffected by the decision, attorney Robert Steele said.
“He takes it in his religious way,” Steele said.
Steele said they did not yet know whether they will file an appeal. He said that decision will be made after sentencing.
For the Smart family, the case was the end of an ordeal. Elizabeth Smart said she plans to return to Paris.
Asked to describe the family’s emotions, her mother Lois said one word came to mind: Victorious. It was the same word her daughter used on the day she returned from captivity.
“I think this is an exceptionally victorious day,” Lois Smart said.